Eva,
I've been in a commited [friends-with-benefits] sexual relationship with a guy for almost 2 years. He's my best friend above all, and we have amazing sexual chemistry.
In the past month, though, he's gone from saying that he loves me to picking fights with me about absolutely NOTHING.
The people who know us both say that he's fighting the fact that he loves me because he's scared of it. People who don't know us say that he's just leading me on. I just can't seem to get a straight answer out of him, and it's incredibly frustrating.
What is your opinion on the situation, and how should I ask him about it?
Relationship questions are inherently hard to answer, because no one really has all the information. You are trying to figure out what is going on, I am trying to figure out what is going on, and neither of us is in this guy's head.
Why is your guy having so much confusion about your just-buddies sex routine? Take a look at your relationship. Here, I'll put it in handy bullet format for you:
- You're each other's very best friends.
- You get along together well.
- You have "amazing sexual chemistry"
- He tells you that he loves you... And you might even say it back.
Gosh! This sounds a lot like a real-live romantic relationship.
Your guy may have just realized that you aren't exactly his friend, but for practical purposes, you're his girlfriend. Surprise! He feels like things are probably getting too close to a real relationship, and your friends are right -- that scares him. He's picking fights because he wants to distance himself from you, so he can pretend you really are nothing more than buddies who happen to have sex. Either he has become emotionally invested, or he's afraid you have and he's panicking.
Does he really love you? Possibly. But think about it: He's getting sex, support, and love from someone who can't play the commitment card because we're "just" friends with benefits. He's got a good thing going, baby, and he doesn't want to screw it up.
It sounds to me like your guy is afraid of commitment, and doesn't want anything to change between the two of you. You can assure him that things will stay the same, but if you slap the 'boyfriend/girlfriend' label on there, things will change. He'll be a taken man and everyone will treat him as such.
There are a lot of reasons for it, but the heart of your issue is that this gentleman is afraid to commit. If you want to try to feel him out, ask him why he prefers your friendship to having a girlfriend. He might have had a bad relationship in the past, he might feel too immature for a girlfriend, he might feel that he isn't worth a girlfriend. Your friends are right, he is fighting becoming too attached, but that might be because he really doesn't want a relationship.
Good luck!
- Eva
